Stars Performing Arts
Photo credit: Heather Regan
“Attend the tale of Sweeney Todd…”
The story of Fleet Street’s murderous barber has been told many times, but this retelling of the grim tale brought a unique spirit to the classic Sondheim show. With an inventive set and an eerie air, Stars Performing Arts’s latest production gave new life–and death–to this macabre musical.
Sweeney Todd
While the folkloric origin of Sweeney Todd goes back hundreds of years, Stephen Sondheim and Hugh Wheeler’s musical adaptation of the story was first produced on Broadway in 1979 and subsequently won a Tony award for Best Musical. It premiered on the West End in 1980, where it also won an Olivier award for Best New Musical. It seems that no matter where you are, people will thirst for blood! In 2007, Tim Burton directed a movie adaptation of the story, with some musical numbers included and some taken out. The show has experienced a few revivals over recent years–notably, in 2023, with Josh Groban and Annaleigh Ashford in the starring roles.
So…what actually happens in Sweeney Todd?
The story opens with a sailor, Anthony Hope, and a previously exiled barber, Benjamin Barker (who chooses to go by Sweeney Todd, in order to hide his identity from the corrupt judge who exiled him in the first place). We hear about the fate of Todd’s wife (Lucy) and daughter (Johanna), and, with the help of a horrendous baker (Mrs. Lovett), he charts a course for revenge upon the judge and his accomplice. But when Sweeney kills a man and is sent into a murderous rage, Mrs. Lovett comes up with a grisly plan… drama, villainy, and many meat pies ensue.
This Production
With its precise blocking and exact timing, this show ran like a well-constructed engine; the largest working part of this machine was the ensemble, which handled the show’s mechanisms with elegance and energy. Throughout the show, these performers switched between playing active participants of the story and narrating its course through the musical’s iconic ballads. With Zachary Flick’s pointed direction and Nathan Nichipor’s sharp choreography, these transitions from narrating chorus, to people of London, and even to participants in the murderous action, flowed seamlessly. The ensemble truly embodied the madness that this musical necessitates–they became a mob in “Pirelli’s Miracle Elixir” and the ensuing contest, directing their rage or excitement to whomever they decided to turn on next. Their fervor turned feverish as they became the lunatics in “City on Fire!”, chaos dispersing into the house as performers fled straight through the center aisle. Given the choral nature of this show, the ensemble is a vital part of the storytelling. With the help of Matthew Brown’s haunting music direction (and the impressive 14-piece orchestra), this company delivered exactly what Sweeney Todd requires: eeriness, paranoia, and those slight uncanny moments that brought the show together.
Smaller performance spaces provide an added challenge, but Noah Beye’s clever scenic design strikingly transformed the space into the crumbling ruins of an abandoned building. This production’s set, constructed by Jack Lockrem, Ada Rideout, and Elliot Mustard, added to the immersion exponentially. Being so absorbed in the environment really allowed me to see the stakes at hand. The set was complemented wonderfully by William Waugh’s lighting–from a bloodbath of red in “Epiphany” to a scatter of blue in “Not While I’m Around,” the lights always matched the scene’s emotional atmosphere. The costumes, designed by Lori Crockett, fantastically blended the older era with modern wear, further illustrating the multigenerational aspect of this tale. But the most eye-catching element of this production was Camryn Powers’s makeup design; from looks strongly reminiscent of old cabarets to modern gothic styles, every single actor’s face was unique, defined, and striking.
No story can exist without conflict, and there are layers upon layers of strife within this one. Dominic Scoville’s Judge Turpin was stoic and cruel, and his apathy to the plight of others around him could make anyone shiver. Alongside him, Cyris Herrera’s Beadle Bamford was as calculating and slimy as ever. And, though Adolfo Pirelli isn’t technically onstage for a long time, James Cronin completely stole the stage in the role: flourishes, bravado, and all. The Beggar Woman was played mysteriously, yet comically, by Sarah Custer. Her switches between the poor, miserable beggar and the grimy, unsettling woman of the street were shocking, but humorous. All in all, the production had more light, amusing moments than expected, and I was pleasantly surprised by the funny moments in numbers like “Pretty Women” and “Kiss Me.”
Speaking of that last number, CJ Glacken and Page Vogel filled the stage with love as Anthony and Johanna, respectively. Glacken’s rich tone and calm demeanor contrasted very well with Vogel’s frantic energy. In “Johanna (Act 2 Sequence),” Anthony’s pain became evident, and his previous sprightly energy gave way to deeper distress and longing. Vogel’s mix of modern and classic soprano showed a strong hold of Sondheim’s work, and her ability to switch between a put-together girl and a panicked, yet headstrong young woman displayed her range across many entangled emotions. Rounding out the supporting leads, Owen Sebunia played a compelling Tobias. He brought smiles and laughs as a charismatic con-boy, and sympathy for his naivety in “Not While I’m Around.” As he fell into madness, it felt like the scene itself was going with him, losing himself and the world all at once.
There are two actors that cannot go without being mentioned: Ben Mutterperl as Sweeney Todd and Kate Walsh as Mrs. Lovett. There could not be a better pair to play this iconic duo than these two. Mutterperl’s decadent voice gave the opening ballad a specific enticement, and he remained grounded throughout most of the first act. His Sweeney was stark and tormented, yet pitiful, making it easy to empathize with him. Of course, when “Epiphany” began, his realizations came to a head, and he leapt right into his descent to madness; Mutterperl even went so far as to break the fourth wall and directly threaten those in the audience. His pain and wrath were only quelled by a submission to what the world was, and of course, by Mrs. Lovett’s almost unthinkable plan. As for Mrs. Lovett? Kate Walsh brought incredible vigor to the iconic leading lady, undeniably driving and bright. From her introduction in “The Worst Pies in London,” she had the audience in her fist, drawing everyone in with her spellbindingly clear voice and witty performance. In her rendition of “By the Sea,” we got to see Lovett’s soft side, as Walsh vulnerably portrayed deep longing and love. Her verse in “Not While I’m Around” added even more to her character’s kindness, though her giddily wicked nature could not be disputed, as shown in “A Little Priest.” And this performance of the Act 1 finale was phenomenal. It was fun, cunning, and playful, and the audience got to see the chemistry between the two scene partners. All told, Mutterperl’s impressively contained performance and Walsh’s unapologetic portrayal completely owned the stage.
It was truly a wonderful production, both immersive and captivating. While we live in a supposedly more civilized world, it left me thinking: how much have we really changed as a society? After all, perhaps today you gave a nod to Sweeney Todd…
Who is it for?
This story certainly isn’t for everyone, but it’s for anyone with a taste for dark humor and dark tales. As a story, Sweeney Todd is more mature: it has murder, revenge, prostitution, and exploitation. Not exactly the lightest themes! Nevertheless, it isn’t all that disturbing, and this production stayed true to that aspect, especially since this production performed the School edition of the script.
I’d put the lower age limit for this show at around 13 or 14, as there simply are some more mature themes that wouldn’t be suitable for a younger audience. However, there were high schoolers in this production, of course, and I believe that if you’re old enough to be a part of a production, you’re old enough to watch it.
While the run of this show is over, Stars Performing Arts always has more shows coming up. To find more information about future Stars shows, visit https://theatrestars.org/